- home
- article
- Mexico's Senate passes judicial reform allowing election of judges despite protester invasion and disruption
Mexico's Senate passes judicial reform allowing election of judges despite protester invasion and disruption
The Mexican Senate has passed a judicial reform bill, allowing citizens to elect judges at all levels, making Mexico the world's first country to do so. The bill was pushed by outgoing President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador and was met with mass demonstrations, diplomatic tensions, and investor jitters. Despite concerns, the bill was passed with 86 lawmakers voting in favor and 41 against, with the ruling leftist party, Morena, barely mustering the required two-thirds majority. The reform has sparked debate, with supporters arguing it will make judges more accountable to the people, while critics claim it undermines the country's system of checks and balances. The bill's passage was preceded by protests and strikes, with demonstrators breaking into the Senate building, forcing the session to be suspended. The reform has also raised concerns among Mexico's trading partners, who warn that it could undermine the country's trade pact.
The demolition of the judiciary is not the way forward.
The regime of corruption and privileges is becoming more and more a thing of the past.
The country's legal system disproportionately favours the affluent and the well connected. It is overburdened and slow. This is true at all levels, which is why impunity is widespread in Mexico.
With now 18 approving it, well, now it's legal.
It's an incredibly important reform, reaffirming that in Mexico there is authentic democracy. The people electing their representatives, electing their public servants in all three branches, that is democracy.
It would have been more decent, dear friend, if you had taken our call and told us 'I am going to betray you.' It would have been more decent.
Never before, in the history of this country, have two branches of government united to destroy the third.
In some countries, such as the US, some state judges are elected, and in others, such as in Bolivia, high-level judges are elected. If this reform passes, it will place Mexico in a unique position in terms of its method for judicial selection.
This does not exist in any other country.
Without strong safeguards to guard against the infiltration of organized crime (in the judicial selection process), an election system may become vulnerable to such powerful forces.
There is little evidence from international experiences that elected judges are less corrupt or less prone to serve special interests than non-elected ones.
Our intention is not violent, we didn't intend to hurt them. But we intend to make it clear that the Mexican people won't allow them to lead us into a dictatorship.
Mexican Judicial Reform
sources
- 1.CNN
- 2.France 24
- 3.Le Monde
- 4.Al Jazeera
- 5.BBC
- 6.The Washington Post
- 7.The Guardian
- 8.ABC News (Australia)
- 9.The Times
- 10.Daily Sabah
- 11.The New York Times
- 12.CTV News
perspectives
- 1.Constitution
- 2.Mexico under Claudia Sheinbaum
- 3.United States–Mexico–Canada Agreement
- 4.Mexican Cartels
- 5.Mexico under Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador
- 6.Judicial Reform
countries
organizations
- 1.Human Rights Watch
- 2.National Action Party
- 3.United Nations
- 4.Citizens' Movement Party
- 5.Institutional Revolutionary Party
- 6.Cornell University
- 7.International Bar Association
- 8.Mexican Supreme Court
- 9.National Regeneration Movement
- 10.Tribunal for Judicial Discipline
- 11.University College London
persons
- 1.Andrés Manuel López Obrador
- 2.Claudia Sheinbaum
- 3.Ken Salazar
- 4.Gerardo Fernandez Norona
- 5.Norma Pina
- 6.Margaret Satterthwaite
- 7.Miguel Ángel Yunes
- 8.Rodrigo Oropeza
- 9.Emiliano Rodríguez Mega
- 10.Alejandro Benitez
- 11.Alejandro Navarrete
- 12.Alistair Bell