- home
- article
- Canadian Judge Steps Down from Hong Kong's Top Court
Canadian Judge Steps Down from Hong Kong's Top Court
Beverley McLachlin, a Canadian judge and former Chief Justice of Canada, announced her decision to retire from her position as a non-permanent overseas judge at Hong Kong's Court of Final Appeal. She will reach 80 years old in July and has expressed confidence in the court's members, their independence, and commitment to upholding the rule of law. This news comes after another British judge, Jonathan Sumption, resigned shortly after a landmark verdict convicting 14 democratic activists for subversion amid a national security crackdown on dissent. Some lawyers have questioned whether the resignations challenge the assumption that having foreign jurists on the court helps protect Hong Kong's international image. McLachlin served as Canada's Chief Justice from 2000 to 2017 and joined the Hong Kong Court of Final Appeal in 2018. In recent years, Hong Kong has experienced a steady crackdown on democracy in the former British colony. It is worth noting that while both judges have expressed confidence in the court's independence, Jonathan Sumption described the environment as "impossible" when he resigned.
A judge may dislike a political system [or] a particular piece of legislation, but where the expertise of a judge is concerned, that judge should follow the evidence and the law in interpreting the law correctly, irrespective of their personal politics.
It is sad and disappointing that our judges are abandoned by a few overseas counterparts and have been so unfairly treated.
The least sign of dissent is treated as a call for revolution.
Hong Kong Retrocession to China
- Four Hong Kong Opposition Members Released After Serving Prison Sentences
- US Sanctions Chinese and Hong Kong Officials for Human Rights Abuses
- Hong Kong police issue arrest warrants for six prominent democracy activists living in exile overseas
sources
- 1.The Guardian
- 2.The Times of India
- 3.CTV News
- 4.ABC News (Australia)
- 5.China Daily
- 6.Financial Times
- 7.Reuters
- 8.Associated Press
- 9.ABC News
perspectives
- 1.US Foreign Policy
- 2.Chinese Foreign Policy
- 3.British Foreign Policy
- 4.US-China Relations
- 5.Protests
- 6.Authoritarianism
- 7.China under Xi Jinping
- 8.Human rights
- 9.Freedom of Speech
- 10.Hong Kong Retrocession to China
- 11.Hong Kong Democratic Movement
countries
organizations
- 1.Hong Kong Court of Final Appeal
- 2.Inter-Parliamentary Alliance on China
- 3.Legislative Council of Hong Kong
persons
- 1.Beverley McLachlin
- 2.Lawrence Collins
- 3.Robert Reed
- 4.Jonathan Sumption
- 5.John Lee
- 6.James Spigelman
- 7.Chung Ching Kwong
- 8.William Gummow
- 9.James Allsop
- 10.Robert French
- 11.Ted Hui
- 12.Patrick Keane